Comparison guide
ChatGPT vs iBacalao for IB IA feedback
Students often ask whether ChatGPT or a dedicated IB tool is better for Internal Assessment revision. ChatGPT is a general assistant; iBacalao is built only for IB Diploma work — it scores every criterion against official rubrics for all 25 subjects and never generates draft text for you.
The right choice depends on what you need: brainstorming and general writing help versus rubric-grounded, criterion-level comments tied to your subject guide. This comparison focuses on the revision use case most students care about before teacher submission.
| Feature | ChatGPT | iBacalao |
|---|---|---|
| Rubric accuracy | Generic advice — no official IB descriptors | Verbatim mark-band descriptors per subject |
| Criterion scoring | Unstructured paragraphs | Per-criterion scores with ranked fixes |
| Academic integrity | Can generate draft text — high risk | Feedback only — never writes your IA |
| Pricing | Free / ~$20/mo Plus | 3 free reviews; from $27.99/mo |
| Subjects covered | Any (no IB rubrics built in) | All 25 IB subjects + EE + TOK |
| Turnitin risk | Text sent to OpenAI | No storage, no submission record |
Frequently asked questions
- Should I use ChatGPT or iBacalao for my Internal Assessment?
- Use iBacalao when you need feedback scored against the official IB rubric for your subject. Use ChatGPT for general brainstorming only — it does not apply verbatim mark-band descriptors and may generate text that breaches academic integrity.
- Can ChatGPT score IB criteria accurately?
- No. ChatGPT gives general advice without referencing the specific mark-band descriptors for your subject and criterion. iBacalao loads the official rubric for all 25 subjects and scores each criterion individually.
- Is using ChatGPT for an Internal Assessment academic misconduct?
- Using ChatGPT to generate analysis, conclusions, or rewritten paragraphs is academic misconduct under IBO rules. Using it for formative feedback on your own writing is a grey area — iBacalao is designed explicitly as a formative comment tool, not a text generator.
- Which is cheaper for IB students?
- ChatGPT has a free tier; Plus is ~$20/month. iBacalao gives 3 free IA reviews with no card, then plans from $27.99/month. iBacalao includes IB-specific rubric scoring that ChatGPT does not offer.
- Does either tool submit my IA to Turnitin?
- Neither submits to Turnitin directly. iBacalao processes your draft for feedback and does not store it. Pasting into ChatGPT sends text to OpenAI's systems — check your school's AI policy for both.
Try criterion-by-criterion feedback on your subject at iBacalao subject feedback or see our full Internal Assessment feedback tools comparison.
